Index regulation

MSCI Oversight and Governance Committees

MSCI provides overall oversight and governance for its indexes through a committee structure. Each of these committees has a Terms of Reference:

 

MSCI equity (and blended) indexes

MSCI Index - Risk and Regulatory Committee

MSCI Equity Index Committee

 

MSCI private real estate indexes

MSCI Real Estate - Risk and Regulatory Committee

MSCI Real Estate Index Committee

 

MSCI indexes

MSCI BMR Oversight Committee

MSCI Index Policy Committee

 

How MSCI Manages Conflicts of Interest

Please see our statement here.

 

MSCI Real Estate Data Provider Code of Conduct                                                           

Data providers to MSCI Private Real Estate Indexes must adhere to our Data Provider Code of Conduct: MSCI Real Estate Data Provider Code of Conduct.

MSCI has been committed to high standards in benchmark administration long before the EU benchmark regulation was enacted, as evidenced through our long history as a respected benchmark provider and our adoption of the IOSCO Principles for Financial Benchmarks (described below). We fully support the aims of the EU benchmark regulation and have been an active contributor to its development from the outset.

Below you can find information about MSCI’s status as a regulated benchmark administrator under the EU benchmark regulation (“BMR”). 

General

On 5 March 2018, MSCI Limited (located and registered at Ten Bishops Square, 9th Floor, London E1 6EG, UK) was granted authorization by the UK’s Financial Conduct Authority (“FCA”) as a UK/EU benchmark administrator. Initially, the authorization covered MSCI equity and blended indexes. On 13 June 2019, MSCI notified the FCA in relation to specific UK MSCI Private Real Estate Indexes used as regulated benchmarks under the BMR.

MSCI Limited is listed on the FCA’s register and on the ESMA register for benchmark administrators. For information on MSCI Limited’s authorization with the FCA, MSCI’s benchmark families and benchmark statements, relevant compliance statements and the indexes covered by MSCI’s authorization, please see:

• Information related to MSCI Limited's authorization
• MSCI equity benchmark family - benchmark statement
• MSCI blended benchmark family - benchmark statement
• MSCI property benchmark family - benchmark statement
• MSCI property fund (with published NAVs) benchmark family - benchmark statement
• MSCI Real Estate - BMR Benchmarks Methodology Specifications

Prior to the date of Brexit, MSCI Limited can be found on both the FCA’s register and on ESMA’s register for benchmark administrators. Pursuant to ESMA's notice on 7 October 2019, as of the date of Brexit, UK administrators (including MSCI Limited) will be removed from the ESMA register and will become third country administrators. However, during the BMR transitional period (as defined in BMR Article 51) EU supervised entities can use third country benchmarks even if they are not included in the ESMA register. This BMR transitional period is being extended for all non-EU administrators until 1 January 2022, and non-EU administrators will have until 1 January 2022 to be permissioned into the EU under the BMR. This extension of the BMR transitional period will allow MSCI to execute its Brexit plans. This does not affect MSCI’s authorization with the UK FCA as a UK administrator, and MSCI will continue to appear on the UK FCA’s register.

MSCI Private Real Estate Indexes – Permissioning process for BMR regulated uses

Because contributors to MSCI Private Real Estate Indexes may be supervised contributors and regulated directly under the BMR, MSCI requires that all BMR regulated uses of MSCI Private Real Estate Indexes are expressly permissioned by MSCI through the formal process explained below. MSCI has also restricted potential BMR regulated use to the following indexes in the UK market:

• the MSCI/AREF UK Quarterly Property Fund Index
• the MSCI UK Annual Property Index
• the MSCI UK Quarterly Property Index
• the indexes with frozen history created from the same index universes as the indexes above that a licensed client requests for a BMR regulated use (such use subject to MSCI’s permission in each instance).

To apply for permission, MSCI clients are required to download the MSCI Private Real Estate Index Application for EU BMR Regulated Use form and send the completed form to MSCI_RealEstate_EUBMR_Use_Application@msci.com. If, after reviewing the application, MSCI approves the MSCI Private Real Estate Index for a BMR regulated use, the MSCI client will be required to sign the permission letter. MSCI will not accept, or reply to, any requests from parties that are not MSCI clients for the relevant MSCI Private Real Estate Indexes.

Use of any MSCI Private Real Assets Indexes, including any MSCI Private Real Estate Indexes, for BMR regulated uses outside this MSCI permission process is strictly prohibited.

For a copy of the MSCI Equity Index policy document on the ESMA Guidelines on ETFs and Other UCITS Issues, please contact MSCI Client Service.

Index constituents information as per ESMA Guidelines can be found here.

MSCI has a long history of defining and adopting best practice with respect to its index policies and procedures, and we support the aims of the IOSCO Principles for Financial Benchmarks.

The International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO), which is an association of organisations that regulate the world’s securities and futures markets, published the Principles for Financial Benchmarks in July 2013, initially calling upon benchmark administrators to disclose their compliance within 12 months of that date and then annually after that.  

MSCI published its first adherence statement on www.msci.com in 2014 and continues to publish annual adherence statements.   

MSCI’s most recent IOSCO adherence statements can be viewed below:

2019 IOSCO report for MSCI Equity and Blended Indexes
2019 IOSCO report for MSCI Private Real Estate Indexes

 

DATA SUBMITTERS TO MSCI PRIVATE REAL ESTATE INDEXES

We ask data submitters to adhere to our MSCI Real Estate Data Provider Code of Conduct so that the submission processes for data included in the MSCI Private Real Estate indexes and benchmarks are in line with the IOSCO Principles and best practices.

The ‘Data Submitter Code of Conduct – IPD Indexes and Benchmarks” has been updated and renamed to the “MSCI Real Estate Data Provider Code of Conduct” on November 26, 2018.

For further information and if you provide data to us, please read the document below:

 

• MSCI Real Estate Data Provider Code of Conduct

In response to feedback from numerous market participants, MSCI has decided to provide information regarding select indexes to help facilitate MSCI’s clients’ determination whether an index qualifies as a “Qualified Index” under Section 871(m) of the Internal Revenue Code.

MSCI Equity Index Policy regarding United States IRS 871(M) regulations relating to the definition of a “Qualified Index”

 

TEG Report on EU Taxonomy – Issued on June 18, 2019 >>Survey Form – MSCI Responses >>Additional Comments from MSCI
EU TEG Interim Report on Climate Benchmarks and Benchmarks’ ESG Disclosures – Issued on June 18, 2019 >>MSCI’s Feedback >>MSCI Questionnaire Response
ESMA consultation on Indices and Recognised Exchanges under the Capital Requirements Regulation – Issued on May 24, 2019 >>MSCI Response
CSA request for comments on the proposed National Instrument 25-102 Designated Benchmarks and Benchmark Administrators and Companion Policy – March 14, 2019 >>MSCI Response
RBI Financial Benchmark Administrators (Reserve Bank) Directions – Issued on February 15, 2019 >>MSCI Response
EU Commission Proposal for a Regulation amending Regulation (EU) 2016/1011 on Low Carbon Benchmarks and Positive Carbon Impact Benchmarks  – Issued on May 24, 2018 >>Annex to the Proposed Regulation >> MSCI Response
ASIC Consultation on Implementing the Financial Benchmark Regulatory Regime – Issued on July 17, 2017 >>MSCI Response
SEBI Discussion Paper on Draft Code of Conduct for Index Providers - Issued on May 31, 2017 >>MSCI responses
ESMA Consultation Paper on draft implementing measures for Benchmarks Regulation (BR)- ESMA /2016/ 723, Issued on May 27, 2016 >> MSCI responses
CFR Consultation Paper on  Financial Benchmarks Regulatory Reform –Issued on March 31, 2016 >> MSCI responses
ESMA Discussion Paper on Benchmark Regulation – ESMA /2016/288, Issued on February 15, 2016 >> MSCI response
SEC Proposed Rule – Investment Company Reporting Modernization (Release No.33-9776) - File No.: S7- 08- 1, issued on May 20, 2015 >> MSCI response
FCA Consultation Paper – CP15/18 on Fair, Reasonable and Non-discriminatory access to regulated benchmarks, issued on June 3, 2015 >>MSCI Responses
ESMA Consultation Paper on draft Regulatory & Implementing Technical Standards (RTS/ITS) for  implementation of MiFID II/MiFIR,  issued on December  19, 2014 >> MSCI Response
ESMA Consultation Paper on draft Implementing Technical Standards on main indices and recognised exchanges under the Capital Requirements Regulation, issued on September 29, 2014 >> MSCI Response
MAS Consultation Paper on Amendments to SFA on Regulation of Financial Benchmarks, issued on July 29, 2014 >> MSCI Response
ESMA Consultation Paper on MiFID/MiFIR, issued on May 22, 2014  >> MSCI Annex to Response 2
ESMA Consultation Paper on Principles for Benchmark-Setting Processes in the EU, issued January 11, 2013 >>MSCI response >>IPD response
IOSCO Financial Benchmarks Consultation Report, issued January 11, 2013 >> MSCI and IPD Response to IOSCO Principles Financial Benchmarks. IPD Consultation Response OICU-IOSCO
EU Commission Consultation Document on the Regulation of Indices, issued September 5, 2012 >> MSCI response

While we strive to provide quality products and services, if you have a formal index complaint regarding our index products, please follow the procedure as outlined below. Formal index complaints include complaints regarding whether a specific index appropriately represents the market, segment or strategy it seeks to measure, complaints regarding a proposed change to the index determination process, complaints regarding an application of the methodology in relation to a specific index determination, and complaints regarding other decisions in relation to the index determination process.

Formal index complaints must be submitted through the web form found here.

MSCI’s formal index complaints policy can be found here. For the avoidance of doubt, this process covers formal index complaints only. For general questions about our equity indexes, please contact MSCI Client Service. For general questions about MSCI Private Real Assets Indexes, please contact the MSCI Real Estate Client Services team via realestate@msci.com.