Implications of Shorting on Cost of Capital and ESG: Empirical Evidence
Apr 19, 2022
Overall, shorting is an essential part of financial-market activity, though it is relatively new in ESG investing. Sometimes there is a debate around short-sales restrictions, and their timing and usefulness in managing market volatility and extreme events. But the debate about the relationship between the shorting of particularly low-ESG-scoring companies and its impact on cost of capital has been consistently one-sided, and this is the topic of this study.
Certain activist investors and advocates of penalizing ESG laggards have claimed that shorting stocks usually leads to an increase in the stock’s cost of capital. While this may be the case for particular activist actions, it is not clear whether an increase in a stock’s shorting demand per se will have a similar effect.
In this report we looked at the relationship between stock-shorting demand and the cost of capital of the constituents of the MSCI World Index, during the period between August 2015 and December 2021. Our findings do not support the hypothesis that an increase in shorting demand leads to an increase in cost of capital. If anything, we find that low-short-interest stocks have had slightly higher cost of capital compared to high-short-interest stocks, though these results were not economically significant.
No significant evidence that higher levels of short selling raise companies’ cost of capital
- Yuliya Plyakha Ferenc, Vice President, MSCI Research
ESG Reporting in Long-Short Portfolios
In this webinar, our speakers will provide an assessment of fund reporting approaches for ESG & climate metrics for long-short portfolios, with recommendations on best practice for ensuring the greatest level of transparency for ESG fund reporting.Explore More
Reported Emission Footprints: The Challenge is Real
Investors’ ability to make comprehensive assessments of companies’ climate profiles relies on being able to analyze trustworthy corporate disclosures of greenhouse-gas emissions. Yet the current state of disclosures remains challenging.Read More
Is There a Short Interest Factor?
We introduce a new integrated short interest factor that combines multiple dimensions of short interest.Learn More