The Implied Temperature Rise of 'Paris-Aligned' Indexes
- Today, 90% of public companies have an Implied Temperature Rise above 1.5 degrees C, making it difficult for a diversified benchmark, including a Paris-Aligned Benchmark Index, to have an Implied Temperature Rise of 1.5 degrees C, or even 2 degrees C.
- The MSCI Indexes that align with the minimum requirements of Paris Aligned Benchmark Indexes exhibited Implied Temperature Rises around 0.8 degrees C lower, on average, than their respective parent indexes, in the range of 2.1 degrees C to 2.2 degrees C.
- While these indexes do not show an Implied Temperature Rise below 2 degrees C today, they are designed to implement year-on-year self-decarbonization so as to be aligned with a 1.5 degrees C target over the long term.
Constructing PAB Overlay Indexes
A PAB version of a cap-weighted parent index, such as the MSCI ACWI Index, first excludes particular categories of fossil-fuel-intensive companies. The MSCI PAB Overlay Index methodology then applies the following required adjustments:
- A reduction in index-level carbon intensity of at least 50% from the parent index
- Subsequent annual reductions in its own index-level carbon intensity by 7% 2
Implied Temperature Rise of MSCI PAB Overlay Indexes vs. Parent Indexes
MSCI Implied Temperature Rise data as of Oct. 29, 2021. Source: MSCI ESG Research LLC, MSCI PAB Overlay Indexes
The holdings of the MSCI PAB Overlay Indexes, as of the end of October, exhibited consistently lower temperatures versus their parent indexes (0.7 degrees C to 0.8 degrees C lower) as a result of these fossil-fuel-related exclusions and decarbonization relative to the parent indexes. On average, they had 66% lower financed emissions. But why do the MSCI PAB Overlay Index holdings not exhibit an Implied Temperature Rise of 1.5 degrees C today when they are designed to align with the goal of a 1.5 degrees C rise? To answer this question, we need to understand what an index Implied Temperature Rise assessment shows us, and what these indexes are designed to do.
Present State vs. Future Decarbonization
The Implied Temperature Rise for an index reflects an assessment of the underlying companies' projected emissions and budgets as measured today, taking into consideration those companies' credible climate-related commitments. It is a forward-looking temperature estimate based on the holdings' current emissions trajectories. It does not, however, take into consideration the index-level year-over-year self-decarbonization that is a crucial feature of the complete index methodology.
As 90% of the world's public companies have an Implied Temperature Rise above 1.5 degrees C,3 it would be exceptionally difficult for a diversified benchmark, including a Paris-Aligned Benchmark Index, to have an Implied Temperature Rise of 1.5 degrees C, or even 2 degrees C. An index with an Implied Temperature Rise of 1.5 degrees C today would likely have a high level of concentration and a significant shifting of weights toward the relatively few companies that have an Implied Temperature Rise of 1.5 degrees C or below. This would pose considerable index-construction challenges in terms of balancing diversification and liquidity,
Additionally, the MSCI PAB Overlay Indexes' annual decarbonization adjustment to achieve a trajectory for 1.5 degrees C alignment cannot be achieved by merely reducing weights to or excluding high-emitting sectors, as the indexes are required to maintain a certain level of exposure to all sectors. Instead, the required 7% annual decarbonization can be accomplished in only two ways:
- The current index constituents reduce their emissions (intensity) compared to the previous year.
- The index constituents are changed so that, in aggregate, the index's emissions are reduced over time.
Further Reading
What Implied Temperature Rise Means for Funds
Net-Zero Alignment: Portfolio Construction Approaches for Investors
Climate Reality Bites: Actually, We Will Not Always Have Paris
Measuring the Temperature of Your Portfolio
Stress Testing Portfolios for Climate-Change Risk
MSCI Implied Temperature Rise Methodology
1”EU climate benchmarks and benchmarks’ ESG disclosures.” European Commission, September 2019.2The minimum year-on-year self-decarbonization for EU PAB benchmark indexes is 7%. This is in line with or beyond the decarbonization trajectory from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) 1.5°C scenario. Please see for more details: “TEG Interim Report on Climate Benchmarks and Benchmarks’ ESG Disclosures.” European Commission, June 2019.3The MSCI Net-Zero Tracker showed that a near-10% decarbonization rate is required for net-zero alignment starting from MSCI ACWI IMI, as of October 2021. See, “The MSCI Net-Zero Tracker: A quarterly gauge of progress by the world’s listed companies toward curbing climate risk.” MSCI, October 2021.
The content of this page is for informational purposes only and is intended for institutional professionals with the analytical resources and tools necessary to interpret any performance information. Nothing herein is intended to recommend any product, tool or service. For all references to laws, rules or regulations, please note that the information is provided “as is” and does not constitute legal advice or any binding interpretation. Any approach to comply with regulatory or policy initiatives should be discussed with your own legal counsel and/or the relevant competent authority, as needed.