What Does It Cost to Exit a Fund?

Blog post
5 min read
November 18, 2026
Key findings
  • Institutional investors holding external funds may face higher transaction costs as regulatory changes in the EU, U.K. and other markets encourage the use of liquidity-management tools.
  • Following the April 2025 U.S. tariff announcement, the estimated cost of redeeming USD 100 million from a global high-yield-bond fund rose from 34 to 49 basis points — a 42% increase.
  • Large daily net fund outflows can substantially increase redemption costs. Investors may use stress testing to assess how large outflows could affect redemption costs.

Mentioned in this blog post:

MSCI LiquidityMetrics

Institutional investors investing through external fund managers may increasingly need to monitor the costs of redeeming their fund investments. When funds sell assets to meet redemptions, they incur transaction costs traditionally borne by the remaining investors. Recent regulatory updates encourage, and in some cases require, funds to use anti-dilution tools (ADTs) that pass these expenses to transacting investors instead. We estimated the transaction costs investors may face when withdrawing their investments from external funds and found that they can rise sharply during market stress, while other investors' redemptions can add substantially to the costs.

The shifting burden of redemption costs 

When investors redeem their external-fund holdings, the fund may need to sell assets to raise cash. These transactions incur costs, including bid-ask spreads and additional market impact.1 Traditionally, the fund absorbs these costs, reducing the value of the investments held by those who remain. This is known as dilution.

ADTs, such as swing pricing and anti-dilution levies, allow funds to pass these costs to the transacting investors instead. Their use is becoming more widespread. New European Union rules, effective from April 2026, require managers of open-end funds to select at least two liquidity-management tools, while new U.K. rules require anti-dilution mechanisms where dilution presents a material risk. Investors in external funds may therefore increasingly need to account for transaction costs when planning withdrawals.

How much can redemption costs rise during market stress? 

To measure the transaction costs associated with ADTs, we model the cost of trading the underlying securities of funds. Transaction costs depend on market conditions and can increase sharply during periods of stress, particularly for funds investing in less liquid assets.2

Following the April 2025 U.S. tariff announcement, the estimated cost of redeeming USD 100 million from a global high-yield-bond fund rose by 42%, from 34 to 49 basis points (bps). Other fixed-income funds also saw substantial increases, while equity funds were less affected. For example, estimated costs climbed by 27%, from 17 to 21.6 bps, for global investment-grade-bond funds, compared with 10%, from 2.9 to 3.2 bps, for developed-market large-cap-equity funds. The increase was driven by wider bid-ask spreads for bonds and mainly by higher market impact for equities. We observed a similar, though less pronounced, rise in transaction costs around the outbreak of the Iran war in February 2026.

The episodes highlight how market stress can affect asset classes differently. Investors withdrawing from funds holding less liquid investments may face not only higher transaction costs in normal conditions but larger increases when markets become turbulent.

Transaction costs jump significantly during periods of market stress 
Loading chart...
Please wait.

Estimated transaction costs for a USD 100 million redemption across six fund groups, expressed in basis points of market value traded. Source: RiskMetrics® LiquidityMetrics® 

Quantifying the additional cost of other investors’ redemptions 

Market conditions are only part of the picture: The total cost of redemption may also depend on how much other investors withdraw from the fund on the same day. Anti-dilution mechanisms used by external funds make an investor’s redemption costs depend on the fund’s total daily net flows. For instance, under swing pricing, all redeeming investors receive the same adjusted NAV, calculated based on the fund's aggregate net flows.

During the April 2025 tariff-related market stress, our estimates show that a USD 100 million redemption amid USD 1 billion in total net outflows could cost 170% more in developed-market large-cap-equity funds, 280% more in small-/mid-cap-equity funds and 220% more in emerging-market equity funds, compared with redeeming the same amount alone.

For fixed-income funds, the effect is considerably smaller, with additional costs of approximately 30% for emerging-market bonds, 16% for global high-yield bonds and 12% for global investment-grade bonds.

The difference between the percentages reflects how transaction costs respond to trade size. Fixed-income assets have higher transaction costs due to wider bid-ask spreads, but their costs are less sensitive to trade size than those of equities. As a result, equity-fund redemption costs are more affected by other investors' withdrawals.

Withdrawing funds on a day with large outflows incurs significant excess costs 
Loading chart...
Please wait.

Estimated transaction costs for a USD 100 million redemption amid a USD 1 billion net fund outflow on April 8, 2025, under tariff-related market stress. Costs are decomposed into half bid-ask spread, market impact and the additional cost associated with the total net fund outflow. All values are expressed in basis points of market value traded. Source: RiskMetrics® LiquidityMetrics® 

How can investors estimate their redemption costs? 

Investors in external funds generally lack access to the funds' full holdings and cannot know in advance how much other investors will withdraw, making redemption costs challenging to estimate. As the use of ADTs becomes more widespread, institutional investors may consider modeling the liquidity of their external fund investments directly. By stress testing potential redemption costs under different market conditions and net-flow assumptions, they can identify funds that may become expensive to redeem from and better assess their portfolio's liquidity risk.

Subscribe today
to have insights delivered to your inbox.

LiquidityMetrics

Setting the standard for liquidity analytics.

A Practical Approach for Analyzing Fund Capacity

When does a fund’s size begin to hinder its performance? Discover a new, data-driven approach to help portfolio managers and risk professionals evaluate fund capacity.

Liquidity Risk Management for Funds: Part 1: Dilution Effects

This paper proposes best practices for fund liquidity risk management. We draw a synthesis from the progress in the field of fund liquidity risk management and address the issue through a systematic formulation of the problem and adoption of the best tools currently available.

1 Market impact is the excess transaction cost beyond the bid-ask component for large trades.

2 We created homogeneous fund groups based on funds’ investment characteristics and constructed a representative portfolio for each. Transaction costs were calculated for these portfolios using MSCI’s RiskMetrics® LiquidityMetrics® model. This approach models the underlying transaction independently of the ADT used by the fund. The results are more directly applicable to swing pricing but can also indicate costs under anti-dilution levies.

The content of this page is for informational purposes only and is intended for institutional professionals with the analytical resources and tools necessary to interpret any performance information. Nothing herein is intended to recommend any product, tool or service. For all references to laws, rules or regulations, please note that the information is provided “as is” and does not constitute legal advice or any binding interpretation. Any approach to comply with regulatory or policy initiatives should be discussed with your own legal counsel and/or the relevant competent authority, as needed.